Do you support "third gender" status for transgenders?

Do you support “third gender” status for transgender?


Transgender groups are one of the most ignored groups in India. Whenever the families come to know about the reality of their child, they find it better to shun the child. Also, transgenders have to suffer innumerable problems in their life. Whether it is education, career or basic living rights, they are denied of equality. Seeing the miserable conditions of transgender, the Supreme Court decided to recognize transgender as third sex in India. Do you support the ruling of Supreme Court?

Yes/

• As nature has made males and females, similarly nature has created transgender, and therefore, they should get the third sex status.

• When people think it important to treat animals with care, why transgender have to suffer the humiliation. After all, they also breathe like other living things.

• Coming to reservation, when the normal people who belong to special quotas are given special reservation, why should transgender denied of reservations?

• Like other people, transgenders also need some respectful source of living and it is possible only when they are recognized in society.

• The impact of ruling is visible as Padmini Prakash becomes first transgender newsreader after the court gave its verdict.

• Transgender face several problems like denial of housing, illegal detention, sex work and many others, which can be put to an end by giving them equal rights in society.

No

• Parents do not shun the children who come under the community of transgender; instead it is the community itself who take those children forcefully from the respective family.

• As the reservation for the OBC and other special categories is not justified, the reservation for transgenders is not justified.

• Transgenders don’t want to be a part of normal society and therefore, no law can forcefully make them as an integral part of society.

• India is a democratic country and everyone deserves equal right by basic law. There is no need to formulate a special law for transgenders.

• Transgenders are already considered as out of society and recognizing them as third gender is in no way different than the normal behavior.

Conclusion

India is a place where discrimination prevails on basis of several factors. Some are discriminated on basis of color; some are discriminated on basis of caste and some on the basis of sex. In a country, where women have to fight for her rights, how can someone expect transgender to get equal rights? The court ruling is justified as it will at least force the companies and educational institutes to consider transgender applicants and provide them with job and education.
Post your comment

    Discussion

  • RE: Do you support "third gender" status for transgenders? -nikhil sahu (11/10/14)
  • yes
  • RE: Do you support "third gender" status for transgenders? -pravesh (11/06/14)
  • Mere declaration of transgender as third gender will not bring the things right .Society have to accept them and society will accept when our constitution accept them.when we are children we do not know about such descrimination,we are told by our elders.therefore there is need to accept them socially.Media can be used to spread awareness regarding this.We are going for safai abhiyan then there is need for this also
    I shall not admire reservation but yes court must go for this decision.
  • RE: Do you support "third gender" status for transgenders? -Nidhi Papneja (11/04/14)
  • Transgender should definitely be treated as the other two genders, as thy r also normal human being, when it is biologically proven tht it is a natural phenomenon thn who are we to discriminate between thm, thy shd be given equal respect and dignity in d society.
  • RE: Do you support "third gender" status for transgenders? -Nidhi Papneja (11/04/14)
  • Transgender should definitely be treated as the other two genders, as thy r also normal human being, when it is biologically proven tht it is a natural phenomenon thn who are we to discriminate between thm, thy shd be given equal respect and dignity in d society.
  • RE: Do you support "third gender" status for transgenders? -Deepa Kaushik (09/24/14)
  • The topic under discussion requires an open mind-set with logical thinking and analysing power. Trans-genders are no new to the world and have been always a topic for discussion, but when we check to any solution to their concern, we wind up our notes to a big zero. The discussions revolve round the same spheres every time and end up with no concrete decision for their concern.

    If at all the Government intends to introduce a ‘third gender’ status at various places of applications and implications, it would be an appreciable move. Trans-genders have always been laughed at without any specific reason or cause, or for that reason for any fault of their own. The way they are born is not within their voluntary decision and their behaviours and mannerisms are altered within their body systems. The third-gender status is just an initiative to get some recognition for this group of people who have been looked down upon so far.

    The third-gender status would definitely help them to apply for the various positions / vacancies, be that for their education purpose or employment. Well educated and employed person definitely gains respect and dignity into the eyes of the people. The civilised thinking would culture them and it could be an initiating factor which could help in raising the living standards of their own kind.

    Just the introduction of the status would not find any relaxation to them, unless our society opens up their ignorant and narrow-minded mind-set. The status could not search them a normal lifestyle. This is something that our society needs to provide them. This change needs to be incorporated right from the childhood, where the child should have respect for the trans-gender and should accept and implicate their mannerisms in a normal way. This sort of thinking could help in changing and re-organising the society, making a way for the trans-genders into and as a part of our community.