Jallikattu - The ban should continue!

Jallikattu – The ban should continue!

Introduction:

On one side, we have the government trying to ban everything and anything controversial and on the other hand the government lifted a ban that agitated more people than it pleased. Jallikattu, the bull-taming game of Tamil Nadu, known for its torturing nature has been given a nod.

Jallikattu was banned four years back when PETA and Animal Welfare Board of India (AWBI) documented and reported the practice of taming animal by torturing and angering them. The AWBI had written to the environment ministry on December 31, advising against any such action to lift the ban but it seems that the centre turned a deaf ear to the suggestion.

Along with Jallikattu of Tamil Nadu, the ban lift also applies to bullock cart racing games of Maharashtra, Karnataka, Punjab, Haryana, Kerala, and Gujarat. Is it just politics for vote banking for the upcoming polls? Would politics always come before welfare and humanity?

Yes:

1. The people of Tamil Nadu had happily welcomed the ban on Jallikattu in the year 2011. They were aware of the nature of the game. Despite the highest court of the country’s decision to ban this so called game, the government took it to themselves to lift the ban. PETA India is also not in support of this act and have decided to move the SC against the centre on this.

2. During Jallikattu, bulls are purposefully scared and petrified and then made to run across the crowd, destroying anything that would come in their way. Various cruel means are adopted to scare and anger the bull like pinching, nailing, stabbing with sticks that have nails at the edges, twisting their tails and even forcefully making them drink alcohol and other drugs. The rope around their nose are painfully yanked and then they are dragged into the crowd of people who further anger the bull. The animals does what it could to get away from the danger that it sees in humans, cruel beings of the highest order.

3. According to the documents by PETA, these bulls also break their bones in order to escape from the crowd continuously trying to toture them. Casualty and death of humans are also alarmingly high during this game. If reports are to be believed, from the year 2012 to 2014, there have been approximately 1100 human casualties and 17 deaths during Jallikattu and other such events. Those visitors who just watch the event and not participate are also at the risk of being hurt.

4. On 7th May 2014, the Supreme Court had strictly and clearly mentioned while banning Jallikattu that bull races and other usage of bulls for performances would not be permitted and the concerned ministry would not modify the notification without the consent of AWBI. The court had also stated that when culture and traditions clash against the laws enacted by the parliament, the law will be given primacy. However, none of this was kept in mind while lifting the ban and hence the SC ruling literally shunned aside.

5. The most hypocritical move by the same government that screamed out loud for ban on beef and to stop cruelty against cow and her progenies came as a shocker for everyone who thought that banning beef was kind and good heartedness of the government. 60,000 people of the country signed the online PETA petition to maintain the ban on Jallikattu. However, the government seems only too concerned about the polls to care for what the people of India actually want.

6. Other countries around the world that entertained sports like bull fighting have looked upon our nation for its compassion towards animals and have stopped these games at many levels. But this lifting of ban and allowing the game of Jallikattu to prosper will mark the black day of our nation that shall now be viewed as “archaic and regressive.”

7. As the environment ministry talks about tradition and reviving of age old cultures, it makes us wonder what in the name of god would promote culture by torturing an animals beyond wits. The event of Jallikattu is usually organized during the Pongal festival. Pongal is the festival of harvest, thanking god for giving us food and good harvest. Mattu Pongal is for celebrating the hard work of cattles that worked through hunger, thirst and pain. What way of thanking these animals should involve exposing them to immense pain? Some families garland these animals, treat them and even worship them to show gratitude making us wonder which of these should be called traditions and need revival.

No:

1. The Pongal festival is supposedly incomplete without this event that is said to signify “manliness” and supremacy of men over animals.

2. Some say that the animal used in Jallikattu is not tortured and rather it is the people holding its horn who are at risk of being hurt but put forth their bravery to tame the bull.

3. According to environment ministry and other government officials, the ban has been lifted but the rules have changed. Regulations have been imposed to prevent cruelty on animals. No drugging or beating or nailing of these bulls would be entertained and the welfare of animal team would check the health of the animals prior to the game and also after the game.

4. Precautionary measures like proper fencing and removing the crowd soon after the animal is tamed would be implemented to prevent viewers from getting injured. The government and the environment ministry have reviewed the Jallikattu game and then allowed the ban lift so there should be no displeasing anyone. PETA and AWBI can always be expected to exaggerate these situations.

Conclusion:

Allowing Jallikattu may have pleased the bull tamers and a majority of people in Tamil Nadu but the greater population of the country is agitated by how the government is keeping its vote banking politics above the welfare of people and its self-claimed kindness towards animals. Even the opposition is not reacting to this disastrous step – anything for appeasing the voters in the upcoming polls.
The biggest mistake yet was not the lifting of ban on Jallikattu but the undermining of institution the way centre carried out the procedure. It should have followed the laws and asked the court to review the ban instead of doing it the unconstitutional way just to appease popular sentiments of the people of Tamil Nadu. An app has soon started doing rounds on the popular sites, calling for people who fancy buying Jallikattu bulls.
Post your comment

    Discussion

  • RE: Jallikattu - The ban should continue! -yamu (01/31/17)
  • not band its they culture
  • RE: Jallikattu - The ban should continue! -Sundar (01/25/17)
  • The author doesn't see to know the ground reality by blindly saying jallikattu is a cruel game a d opposing the game or whatever. Bulls cannot be fed alcohol as blood sample s are taken before and after. They cannot be pierced with nails as there are umpteen cameras In side the gate. There are other restrictions as well. The cruelty hype is a ploy by peta who have a hidden agenda. Pls understand the basics by verifying in person before blindly supporting the ban.
    If native breeds are banned allowed to perish then we will be at the mercy of mncs. The.dairym industry is worth more than a lakh crore. This we will hand over in a.platter to.them if.we.succumb to.their.tactic's. Check pETA stories. What were they doing in Spain where the bull is killed at the end. Why not ban non veg food so.that animals can be spared. Don't be a hypocrite
  • RE: Jallikattu - The ban should continue! -Chandra (01/22/17)
  • Jallikattu has been in news since a last few days. It is an important festival of Tamilnadu and even a lot of celebrities back it up as an inseparable part of Pongal celebrations.

    What I read here is some material for GD giving both the positive and negative aspects of the topic which I appreciate. You can go with whichever side you may like....as a student I find it beneficial.
  • RE: Jallikattu - The ban should continue! -Mani (01/21/17)
  • Thisis the stupidest article i have ever read, wondering how did you even becm a journalist, literraly all the figures are insane, 1100 deaths??? seriosuly,?? n n Kangeyam bulls are calm animals??? One humble request, you got every right to oppose Jallikattu,.. Shout BAN Jallikattu but get your facts right.. And Please do a little research and get your numbers and logic right, and then oppose it, totally fine.. But dont simply throw rubbish, you would have only seen 2-3 videos from peta, im sure.. u r fit only to gozip n not to write any article..
  • RE: Jallikattu - The ban should continue! -Marsh (01/19/17)
  • What most people who signed the petition for continuing the ban on jallikattu is that it is not cruel and gory as media states it to be. Bulls used in this sport were used for ploughing. But now they have been replaced with tractors and other modern machinery. So this sport actually prevents the extinction of the native species of bulls. The number of bulls have reduced greatly over the years.
    PETA complained about the way the bulls are treated in this sport but does that mean all the people who have pets are cruel to them. No! There are just a minority of rule breakerso whilst the rest of them occur peacefully. Please understand what is jallikattu and then post such stuff.


  • RE: Jallikattu – The ban should continue! -sonu malik (02/03/16)
  • career ride put good and real point in favor and against the topic which really help the aspirants to make their views and to come on a solid dicision.
  • RE: Jallikattu – The ban should continue! -Shashank (01/31/16)
  • Amazing points both in favor as well as in opposition.I would say - "Good work CarrerRide..Keep Going. Latest GD topics are heartedly welcome!"

You may like